Match Report: Wigan 4 St Helens 23
Posted by Bilko on July 23 2016 - 17:53

Extended News

Wigan Warriors v St Helens - First Utility Super League 21 - Round 23
Friday 22nd July 2016. Kick Off 8:00pm at DW Stadium.

Match Report

When you win eight matches in a row you can put the attacking woes to the back of your mind but here against St Helens they became exposed in full woeful indignity.

The first fifteen minutes of the second half was non stop Wigan attack but our style seems to be akin to going into battle against machine gun fire with just a spoon for a weapon. Turgid, rancid, horrible stuff.

If we win the semi final next week I won't be worried one jot about this one but it has set massive alarm bells ringing.

I'm not convinced Sam Tomkins was fit and I feel some of our pack was still finding some match fitness compared to Saints who've been pretty set fair for a few weeks but saying that, the pack wasn't the problem. It was the creativity and we had nothing apart from grubbering through in desperate hope. Matty Smith was pretty anonymous and you can't afford that in big games.

Saints meanwhile were excellent. Had a lot of fight and desire and looked like a side that were aiming up this game for a big performance. You should expect that in a derby but I'm still adamant that the bigger game for Wigan is next week.

I didn't think Saints were twelve points better than Wigan at half time to be honest but a dreadful error on half way by Dan Sarginson followed by a bit of luck in Saints getting away with having no one at the play the ball turned the tide and in a blink it was 16-4 at the break.

Wigan had scored a nice try with Lewis Tierney touching down a George Williams grubber to the left corner but two penalties either side of that by Mark Percival made it 4-4. Then the two tries, first for Percival then Morgan Knowles, had the visitors 16-4 by the break.

Second half saw Wigan getting numerous chances to hit back but the crapness of Wigan's attack was obvious and Saints were able to practically shut up shop. I reckon at least seven attempts at the line were thwarted. Good defence perhaps but I thought the gaps were there for Wigan to expose but I don't think they'd have spotted a skyscraper in New York the way this was going.

Saints glossed their performance with a late drop goal from Luke Walsh and a nice try from James Roby for a final score of 23-4. Their was also a late bit of drama between Frank-Paul Nuuausala and Louie McCarthy-Scarsbrook but it was like a toddler version of Neil Cowie and Adam Fogerty all those years ago. The biff is dead and Wigan's attack is on life support! I'd say I hope for better next week but it's hard to be any worse!

Team Sheets

- Wigan Position St Helens 1
1 Sam Tomkins Full Back Jonny Lomax 1
5 Dom Manfredi

Right Wing

Jack Owens 22
4 Dan Sarginson Centre Matty Fleming 24
20 Oliver Gildart Centre Mark Percival 4
22 Lewis Tierney Left Wing Adam Swift 5
6 George Williams Stand Off Jordan Turner 3
7 Matty Smith Scrum Half Luke Walsh 7
21 Ryan Sutton Prop Alex Walmsley 8
16 Sam Powell Hooker James Roby 9

Ben Flower


Greg Richards

14 John Bateman 2nd Row Louie
25 Willie Isa 2nd Row Joe Greenwood 20

Sean O'Loughlin


Jon Wilkin

8 Dom Crosby Substitute Kyle Amor 10
17 Lee  Mossop Substitute Atelea Vea 11
24 Frank-Paul Nuuausala Substitute Luke Thompson 17
28 Jake Shorrocks Substitute Morgan Knowles 28
- Shaun Wane Coach Keiron Cunningham -

Score Sheet

Wigan Warriors 4


St Helens 23

Tries (1):
Lewis Tierney


Tries (3):
Mark Percival
Morgan Knowles
James Roby

Matty Smith 0/1
--- Goals:
Mark Percival 5/5
--- --- Drop Goals:
Luke Walsh 1

Scoring and Incident Pattern

5th Minute Wigan 00 St Helens 02

Penalty Goal: Mark Percival (1/1)

11th Minute Wigan 04 St Helens 02

Try: Lewis Tierney

Wigan 04 St Helens 02 Missed Conv: Matty Smith (0/1)
24th Minute Wigan 04 St Helens 04

Penalty Goal: Mark Percival (2/2)

33rd Minute Wigan 04 St Helens 08

Try: Mark Percival

Wigan 04 St Helens 10 Conversion: Mark Percival (3/3)
38th Minute Wigan 04 St Helens 14

Try: Morgan Knowles

Wigan 04 St Helens 16 Conversion: Mark Percival (4/4)
Half Time Wigan Warriors 04 St Helens 16
73rd Minute Wigan 04 St Helens 17

Drop Goal: Luke Walsh

75th Minute Wigan Sin Bin

Frank-Paul Nuuausala (Pulling Hair)

75th Minute St Helens Sin Bin

L.McCarthy-Scarsbrook (Hair Pulled)

79th Minute Wigan 04 St Helens 21

Try: James Roby

Wigan 04 St Helens 23 Conversion: Mark Percival (5/5)
Full Time Wigan Warriors 04 St Helens 23


Phil Bentham

Penalties Conceded

Wigan 7 St Helens 10

Match Attendance



Rain Shower Early in the Match. Muggy.